Please confirm Oak
- Thread starter Andy S.
- Start date
-
Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.
We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.
We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil. -
Super Cedar firestarters 30% discount Use code Hearth2024 Click here
- Status
![[Hearth.com] Please confirm Oak](/talk/data/attachments/135/135400-302311b1901fca5d16ae02cda6106242.jpg?hash=JSQGc1vNxo)
Black Cherry? Got a better end grain pic? Should be able to see the rays if it's Oak.
Why do you want only Oak? The way we do it here is, grab the wood 'til it's all gone, then figure out what kind it is.
Why do you want only Oak? The way we do it here is, grab the wood 'til it's all gone, then figure out what kind it is.
Point taken! I'm not far enough ahead to be a wood snob but it is a bit out of the way and my 2nd instance this year where the yard is on a big slope with houses very close to each other. The homeowner said his tree people told him it was Oak but I had my doubts so I came to the pros.
I cant see anything from the pics. I stopped and bought a facecord of wood once from a homeowner and I asked him what the wood was. He said he wasnt sure what it was. But after talking to him for a while it turned out that he was a carpenter with the carpenters union and he knew my father. The wood was Ash and it was loaded with powderpost beetle holes and that powdery frass. I was worried about spreading bugs but I took it anyway. It was a nice load great wood.
The point I was making is that the homeowner fully knew what wood he had. Alot of people tell you they have oak.
Shawn Curry
Member
Another vote for Black Cherry. Mature bark in small flaky plates; younger bark black with lenticels. I have tons of this on my property.
The density is the same as Red Maple (JH 950), and it smells great when burned (my primary smoker fuel).
The density is the same as Red Maple (JH 950), and it smells great when burned (my primary smoker fuel).
Last edited:
nrford
Minister of Fire
Paulywalnut
Minister of Fire
I agree with nrford. One on the left looks like a big Black walnut branch split. Greenish black heartwood.
nrford
Minister of Fire
jaychino415
Member
Yeah, that was one thing I didn't like about my Black Cherry guess; The heart looks kind of grainy to be Cherry. Bark didn't look like Walnut to me either, though...
The bark is shown on the round to the right. I've split a lot of wood in the past few months and this was the first time my Fiskars bounced off. I was able to split some of the smaller rounds in one shot but had to hit the larger ones just right. It was also a little stringy. Also... it was recently dropped and measured 25% on a fresh split.
Last edited:
smokedragon
Minister of Fire
Not oak. I think with the bark and the center it is some sort of cherry tree as well. Either way, fruit and nut trees make good firewood, so split away.
I thought it was storm damage. Didn't see any internal damage on what I split. I will split a couple of more rounds tonight to check on odor. Up until Mr. Ford weighed in that it was NOT Black Cherry I was sure it was based on the feedback here and other pics I saw on various threads. The color difference is easily explained... I dumped my high end cell phone and plan in favor of saving some money (this [insert inappropriate political reference] has been devastating for me) and the phone I have takes lousy pics. I'm convinced I have a mid-range BTU pile of free BTU's that may be several things but none of them Oak.
- Status
