Boiled Linseed Oil as a Finish??

[bwise.157]

A question for all the woodworkers out there: What is the best finish to use on top of Boiled Linseed Oil?

I am making a couple bench seats from an old oak plank that is 12" wide and 2" thick for my wife (making two 48" benches from a 16' long plank). This will be for inside the house. We want a rustic look, so I don't want a dark, glossy finish that will hide the character of the wood. I have put one coat of BLO on the plank so far, and love the way it looks. I was planning on several more coats.

What is the best finish on top of the BLO? Clear satin polyurethane? Or, just leave the BLO finish as the only thing?

This is what it looks like so far.


I am a rookie at this, so any advice is appreciated!

 

[DUMF]

A question for all the woodworkers out there: What is the best finish to use on top of Boiled Linseed Oil?

I am making a couple bench seats from an old oak plank that is 12" wide and 2" thick for my wife (making two 48" benches from a 16' long plank). This will be for inside the house. We want a rustic look, so I don't want a dark, glossy finish that will hide the character of the wood. I have put one coat of BLO on the plank so far, and love the way it looks. I was planning on several more coats.

What is the best finish on top of the BLO? Clear satin polyurethane? Or, just leave the BLO finish as the only thing?

This is what it looks like so far.
View attachment 189032

I am a rookie at this, so any advice is appreciated!

NO ! Not much will cover over boiled linseed oil. Either get rid of this finish with solvents or stay with more coats of linseed oil.
Nice look but attracts dirt, but easy to recoat.
Next time look at the Minwax finishes for durability and variety.

 

[Lake Girl]

http://www.popularwoodworking.com/w...s-schwarz-blog/linseed-oil-ancient-friend-foe

It's an interesting read...

 

[mustash29]

You may want to do some more sanding. Maybe with a belt sander. The pic looks like it has residual shadows or marks from a huge circular saw blade that run from north west to south east.

I like the current look. I am a huge fan of the "This end up" or "crate" furniture that is made from southern yellow pine with a hand oiled finish. I have their office desk and continually look for dressers & book shelves on CL. I also have a cheap (Walmart) but classy looking end table and coffee table that has an oiled finish. We dust & clean them regularly with a damp cloth. Once or twice a year they get wiped down with "Old English lemon oil" and they look fantastic. It takes a day or two for the lemon oil to soak in but once it does they are dry to the touch, not sticky, not tacky & next weeks dust wipes right off with a damp cloth. If you get a nick or scratch just massage a bit of the lemon oil into it and it basically disappears. You can't do that with stain & a polyurethane top coat.

 

[bwise.157]

http://www.popularwoodworking.com/w...s-schwarz-blog/linseed-oil-ancient-friend-foe

It's an interesting read...

I have read this article in the past, and that's why I wanted to ask and see if someone has used an oil based stain over top of BLO. Many sites on the internet mention the possibility of using an oil based stain after BLO, but I just wasn't sure about it. Thx!

 

[bwise.157]

You may want to do some more sanding. Maybe with a belt sander. The pic looks like it has residual shadows or marks from a huge circular saw blade that run from north west to south east.

I like the current look. I am a huge fan of the "This end up" or "crate" furniture that is made from southern yellow pine with a hand oiled finish. I have their office desk and continually look for dressers & book shelves on CL. I also have a cheap (Walmart) but classy looking end table and coffee table that has an oiled finish. We dust & clean them regularly with a damp cloth. Once or twice a year they get wiped down with "Old English lemon oil" and they look fantastic. It takes a day or two for the lemon oil to soak in but once it does they are dry to the touch, not sticky, not tacky & next weeks dust wipes right off with a damp cloth. If you get a nick or scratch just massage a bit of the lemon oil into it and it basically disappears. You can't do that with stain & a polyurethane top coat.

I thought about sanding some more, but we actually like the raw look of the plank. The plank is very old, and was pulled out of a barn that was in my family for 150+ years. We were trying to keep a piece of the family history alive without altering it too much. I don't exactly know how old the plank is, but it has some age to it.

That picture was taken about 30 minutes after my first coat of BLO, so it hasn't had a chance to absorb much yet. I will give it a few days to dry, then apply another coat.

I have no problem reapplying an oil to the plank once a year or so, if needed. More than likely the bench will be for decoration and not actually used much for sitting.

 

[Longstreet]

I don't have time for a detailed response right now, but I will get to it this afternoon.

Keep doing what you are doing. You can put both oil and water based varnishes over boiled linseed oil. This afternoon, I will let you know why I think water based may fit your project.

 

[Montanalocal]

This site has a lot of info about linseed oil and linseed oil paint. I have been using it to refinish my deck and log home. Their raw linseed oil is a fantastic product. I would never be without it.

http://www.solventfreepaint.com

 

[sportbikerider78]

Can't you get the same look with a normal stain? What is the benefit?

All poly finishes for me inside the house. The less work the better.

 

[tigeroak]

I have never used BLO as a finish and I have refinished more than most people will ever see. I would use a wax like bri wax and put on 2-3 coats and buff it out with a soft cloth. I use a vinyl sanding sealer 1 coat then sand between coats of a high end lacquer up to 4 coats . I use this for years on antique furniture. I would not put a poly on a dog house. It will not hold up. Put a refinished poly item in the rain and one I done and see which one changes to white. I have read on the back of their poly cans after a few years in traffic areas it will need to be replaced.

 

[mike van]

You can get the same look from one of the Danish oil finishes, then follow it with oil base poly. We used Watco oil on on the chestnut kitchen I made almost 30 years ago, and followed it with 3 coats of poly [oil base] except for a few wear spots, it still look good. All our [oak] floors, poly too. I like it. No, outside in the rain it will not hold up, but what does? The walnut on this desk was done 15 years ago, poly over Watco oil.

 

[BenTN]

I just finished a barnwood credenza with a poly/oil mix. 1 part mineral spirits, 1 part BLO, 1 part minwax wipe on gloss polyurethane. I will try and post pics in a bit. I love this finish, it keeps a rustic, feel good to touch finish. the trick I have found is hand wiping/rubbing the last coat, the gloss stays more of a satin.

 

[BenTN]

Here is a pic of the top. 3 coats of the poly/oil.

 

[bwise.157]

Here is a pic of the top. 3 coats of the poly/oil.

That is about the look I am going for. I have been doing some reading, and found lots of good information about doing the mineral spirits, BLO and oil based clear finish combination.

Do you sand down the finish at all between coats?

 

[BenTN]

000 steelwool between coats. you made need more than 3 coat depending on how thirsty the wood is. that pic doesn't do the finish justice imo. try it on a scrap piece and see what you think.

 

[BenTN]

Was going to mention. if you would like to keep the sawmill/ ruff sawn look, try sanding with fine grit 120+ which leaves alot of the saw marks but smooth to touch.

 

[Lake Girl]

Old weathered wood is usually thirsty wood! Just refinished my Muskoka (Adirondack) chairs and they could still use another coat or two...

PS Thanks for the additional info. Have some rough cut pine from a tree in our yard and was hoping to keep the rustic feel but not the slivers!

 

[bwise.157]

This just needs a couple coats of an oil based varnish/mineral spirits mixture yet. Two coats of BLO applied that really brought the life back to a weathered plank of oak.

 

[EatenByLimestone]

BLO and furniture wax is a fine finish to use indoors.