Genevas, Timber Heat, O'malleys or Stove Chow????

[CD2011]

Oh yeah, we waited too long to put in an order at a local place, so today we hunted for our first ton of pellets!

Choices are:

Stove Chow from Home Depot
O'Malley's from TSC
TSC brand from TSC
Timber Heat from Lowes
Geneva from a local stone and gravel place


Do you love any of these? Absolutely hate any of these? Think any of them are just ok?

Thanks,
Cindy

 

[daffonce]

Which local pellet place? Pellets direct? If you want high end you could go with royal fireside they are carrying okanagan gold spruce pointe and la cretes all top notch. Or go with the pinnacle okanagan douglas fir.

 

[Phoenix Hatchling]

Hated Omallys. Be very cautious with the TSC brand pellets as these can be your worst nightmare. If there's a flag on the bag...run!

 

[Tonyray]

Oh yeah, we waited too long to put in an order at a local place, so today we hunted for our first ton of pellets!

Choices are:

Stove Chow from Home Depot
O'Malley's from TSC
TSC brand from TSC
Timber Heat from Lowes
Geneva from a local stone and gravel place


Do you love any of these? Absolutely hate any of these? Think any of them are just ok?

Thanks,
Cindy

Stove Chows get a bad Rap from some because they are sold at HD. Actually, they are HD's most popular seller.. Some call them Shoulder pellets [to be used when it;s not bitter cold yet] But during last years Polar Vortex, they kept us plenty warm using a Harman at half throttle.
[They are Hardwoods bagged and distributed by Energex American.] Very hot but get a lot of Ash which if u vacuum your stove regularly, no biggie.
Very good pellets IF u want to stay under the 250.00 ton price. Last year, 229.00. this year, 239.00
. Posters will chime in on the other pellets as I can only speak for Chows and Energex hardwoods.don't see much difference in either.
You will find on this board everyone has the're favorites which run from A-Z..
Don't forget that the Brand/make Stove plays as much or more of a part than the pellets which is why you will read that a certain brand is Crap["clogged up my stove"] while others will Swear by the same pellets." Best pellets I ever burned"...

 

[CD2011]

Thanks for your responses...

We live in north central Mass. and last year ordered from Hubbard's Farm... as I said, we have waited too long to put in an order (lesson learned!) and they have no pellets at the moment, but we can order some and get delivery in November. So we are looking for something to get us started for the winter. (I hate being cold and we have had a few days of cold weather recently so we have already run the stove this year!!)

Royal Fireside is a good distance away from us, so not really an option at this point, but thanks for the suggestion.
And the O'Malleys did have a flag on the bag, we will seriously consider your advice.

Thanks again,
Cindy

 

[Tonyray]

Thanks for your responses...

We live in north central Mass. and last year ordered from Hubbard's Farm... as I said, we have waited too long to put in an order (lesson learned!) and they have no pellets at the moment, but we can order some and get delivery in November. So we are looking for something to get us started for the winter. (I hate being cold and we have had a few days of cold weather recently so we have already run the stove this year!!)

Royal Fireside is a good distance away from us, so not really an option at this point, but thanks for the suggestion.
And the O'Malleys did have a flag on the bag, we will seriously consider your advice.

Thanks again,
Cindy

Nothing wrong with these..

 

[Tonyray]

Hated Omallys. Be very cautious with the TSC brand pellets as these can be your worst nightmare. If there's a flag on the bag...run!

Disagree about the flag/Agree about TSC..

 

[Phoenix Hatchling]

Thanks for your responses...

We live in north central Mass. and last year ordered from Hubbard's Farm... as I said, we have waited too long to put in an order (lesson learned!) and they have no pellets at the moment, but we can order some and get delivery in November. So we are looking for something to get us started for the winter. (I hate being cold and we have had a few days of cold weather recently so we have already run the stove this year!!)

Royal Fireside is a good distance away from us, so not really an option at this point, but thanks for the suggestion.
And the O'Malleys did have a flag on the bag, we will seriously consider your advice.

Thanks again,
Cindy

No the one with the flag from TSC is the one to avoid.

 

[Tonyray]

No the one with the flag from TSC is the one to avoid.

gotcha..

 

[Peterfield]

Sent you PM.

 

[Big Pat]

I went through 3 tons of Geneva last year. I'd call them a middle of the road pellet. Decent heat, moderate ash. I'd like something hotter in the heart of winter, but would not hesitate to grab them again for the shoulder season.

 

[Mr. Spock]

I have burned Geneva as well and still do. In my experience they throw heat, are ashy and you may have to scrape the burn pot daily but your P43 will digest them just fine.

 

[Pellet-King]

Go fer the Chow's, solid pellet, Timber Heat's not bad either, there rebagged Dry Creek

 

[Tonyray]

Sent you PM.

who?

 

[CD2011]

who?

Peterfield sent a PM to me...

 

[Tonyray]

Peterfield sent a PM to me...

ok..thought was me.

 

[Peterfield]

Sorry guys, should have clarified who the recipient was.

 

[Tonyray]

Sorry guys, should have clarified who the recipient was.

Don't ever do it again

 

[Peterfield]

Aye aye, captain!

 

[BrotherBart]

 

[oliveone]

chow or timer are both are alright pellets

 

[CBL]

In order, what I would buy...

1) Stove chow
2) Geneva's
3) TSC (as long as they're MWP's)
4) Timber heat
5) Omalleys

 

[PelletFiend]

I would just say that while the Stove Chows are hot, I thought they had a pretty good amount of ash. Heavy stuff that clings onto the inside of the stove.

I liked their heat, but I tend to buy for heat AND low ash. I really want to keep my system clean and low maintenance. We tend to burn up to 4 tons a season, so my hope is to keep the chimney clean outs to a minimum.

 

[cold front]

Timber Heat is re-bagged Dry Creek.

 

[Tonyray]

I would just say that while the Stove Chows are hot, I thought they had a pretty good amount of ash. Heavy stuff that clings onto the inside of the stove.

I liked their heat, but I tend to buy for heat AND low ash. I really want to keep my system clean and low maintenance. We tend to burn up to 4 tons a season, so my hope is to keep the chimney clean outs to a minimum.

yes.. they can be Ashy...