Hearthstone vs Progress, bee in bonnet

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
It's hard to control how long the cat stays in pure cat mode, at least on my stove. If the stovetop hits around 500ºF in cat mode the firebox always self ignites, ending pure cat mode. If I wanted to get firebox flames a little earlier, I could open up the air when the stovetop hits maybe 400ºF and get an earlier flame in the firebox, which would be "hybrid" cat mode.

Tom would certainly know the likely failure mechanism of current combustor technology but I'm doubtful that decreasing the transition time to firebox flames would meaningfully impact combustor life. I think combustor longevity has to do with maintaining the integrity of the aluminum oxide coating which is applied to the foil substrate. Using WS's words: "The aluminum oxide on the surface of the foil protects the metal substrate from oxidation that would otherwise occur to the metal substrate at the operating temperatures of the wood stove. It increases the longevity and durability of the catalyst."

How this impacts combustor life expectancy is debatable at least with my level of understanding.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Todd
The Progress is AMAZING. Put 23 pounds of wood on coals at 9:30 PM. At 5:30 AM the room was 70, stove still warm, coals. Put 22 pounds in at that point. No more since then. It’s 73 in here and the stove is still radiating like mad. With the Jotul I would have woken up to a cold stove, a struggling mini split, and 65 degrees. I’d have put about 35 pounds in by now in several loadings, and it would just be getting up to this temp by now. Oh, it was about 7F overnight and this morning, gradually rising to about 20 now. I am a bit worried about warmer weather, but mini split, and small fires I guess. A lot harder to get the cat to fire with a small fire, I decided with the break in fires.
 
Don't even bother trying to engage the cat if the load is too small (like a quarter or less full).
Just make a small fire to warm up the stove with the cat lever disengaged and it will burn fairly clean and works well for taking the chill out.