Hey, everyone,
What a great bunch of responses!
I apologize for not getting back sooner, but I’m been having some computer problems, that started soon after I made my garage tent post.
So, you’ve all given me some great ideas/things to consider/brands to check out.
I especially appreciated the comments regarding snow handling.
Now, For Some Individualized Comments/Questions:
Savagefactor7
Thanks for the input on the Quonset hut style.
I also appreciate the tip on doubling them up, for greater length, but for my application (trying to keep my truck dry) I don’t think that would work too well, as rain would come down between them, no? Or did you figure out a solution for that? If so, I’d like to hear more about it.
Gooserider,
Hey man, how are you? I know I’ve been away awhile, but I’ll be more of a presence real soon, as I belatedly either get serious about my stove install, or hire it out--either way, I’ll have lots 'o questions! LOL
Your 12’ X 24’ X 12’ sounds like exactly what I need--how high are your door openings, roughly?
Against advice, I too will have a problem with snow on one side (chicken wire garden fence will be less than 2’ away) and on the other side, too, actually, as my “junk pile” of covered OPE is about 2’ away on the other side. I know that’s not ideal for the shelter (OR for the OPE) but I anticipate selling/junking/moving that pile out, possibly by next year, and I’m hoping some of the snow will melt/flow through the chicken wire fence, so your report of blowing snow right on the side of the shelter makes me feel better about my situation. (Other potential sites on our property are either in the “free fire zone” of falling limbs, suffer poor drainage, or are not level (or a combination of all three).
How many earth augers did you use? How deep did they go?
Thanks for the brand recommendation and suggestions!
MANIAC,
I’ve posted this query on a total of three sites, and so far, you win the award for most outrageous report of snow-survivability!
By the end of the winter there was so much snow around it you could only see very top from the outside and it never failed.
I saw “MDM” associated with Rhino, I believe, but I have not seen the “Shelter King” name. I’m sure if I call Rhino, they’ll explain the name game to me. Given it’s snow performance, I’ll try to track down the “Shelter King” brand and check it out.
Mike,
I’ve heard some great things about the Cover-It brand (like 11 and 13 year lifespans!)
24’ X 32’ is HUGE my man! Makes me feel better about managing a 12’ x 24’ job.
That SUCKS that your family and friend watched it collapse! (They must be related to some of my own tribe---LOL).
I can run a snow blower down one side of it, to remove the snow, and I guess it’s gonna suck on the fence side. I’ll try to keep it as narrow as possible, but I don’t think I want a 10’ wide tent with an 8’ snowplow (not sure how wide the doors would be on a 10-footer, so I was thinking of going with the 12-footer, as even with the plow angled, I have visions of knocking it down by accident, in a blizzard….)
You register another vote for the Quonset-style’s superior ability to handle snow--duly noted.
I will definitely task my neighbor with the snow removal, if/when I am away. Let me ask you, is all that is required, is to “fluff” the underside of the roof, with a push broom to get the snow to migrate off of the roof, and down the sides? I mean, I’m sure it would help to blow the snow away from the sides, but can the roof be cleared from the inside, in the manner I describe, or is there something else that is required?
TurboZ,
Wow--13 years--awesome! Let me ask you--was yours completely in the shade, or is it not very windy, or to what do you attribute that extra-long lifespan to?
Another happy “Cover-It” owner, and another vote for the Quonset hut style. Hmmm….
Do you clear the snow off of it in the manner I describe above (“bouncing” it off of the top, by pushing up on the inside with a broom?) or do you have another method?
Really appreciate the brand/style recommendations.
A Shelby, huh? Damn! :coolsmile:
I have one additional question for the assembled: What types of doors do you recommend?
Some have the option of either roll ups or zippered “barn” doors (I guess?).
Re: doors, here is my intended usage:
I want to get my truck, WITH plow, inside. The truck, a super cab/longbed, with plow, will be 24’ long (that seems outrageous, doesn't it?) :bug: . So I’ll need a 12’ X 24’ tent, IMO, minimum.
For the first time in 20+ years, I have a vehicle whose finish I care about, hence my desire to get the new (to me) F-250 inside. The best place I can put this (out from under the perennially-falling tree branches) means I will have to be able to drive straight through it, on occasion. So, re: door types, I would like to know:
a) Are roll-up doors less likely to result in paint damage? (I fear that an unzippered, “side-hung” door might come loose, and the zipper could beat up the paint on the truck, if it were at all windy out (and it's often windy here).
b) Which doors are easier to open and close? I would like to leave them open as much as possible (at least on one end) but anticipate closing them during snowstorms (after I get the plowing done, of course.)
c) Which doors are more durable? At $100. for a roll-up door--apiece--(if I recall correctly) I don’t want them to fail before the rest of the tent does.
d) How do the roll-up doors actually work? By that I mean:
1) Do they zipper down the sides, when down, and how are they raised (I.e., is there some kind of cord you pull, or do you just wind them up around a pole and tie them in position?
2) How difficult are they to put up--can ONE PERSON do it easily?
Thanks again, everyone, for all of your thoughtful comments and suggestions. I especially enjoyed hearing how long your shelters lasted, how much they were, and what you liked/didn’t like/would do differently if you were to get another such shelter.
All the best,
Peter