Thermocouples, Cat and Pipe Monitoring, Progress Hybrid

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.

John Lehet

Feeling the Heat
Hearth Supporter
Nov 9, 2013
351
Vermont
After about 3/4 of last winter with it I’m fairly comfortable with understanding burning the Progress with just the stovetop thermometer, but for a few reasons I’d like to understand what’s going on in more depth. A lot of what I want to understand is how hot the cat is getting with a big load of fuel as I’m going to bed. Online I’ve seen some users with distortion in the steel that holds the cat on the Progress (and the cat gets bent too when that happens it). My chimney sweep got me a little nervous this summer as we were nerding-out about stoves. He has seen that in these stoves. I assume what’s happening in those cases is the cat is running hotter and longer than the supporting steel is meant to handle. I assume this happens mainly when the stove goes to black box mode if shut down too far, when the cat is getting fed all the smoke from all that fuel, but it’s a mystery to me. Is the cat raging hot when the stove is in the mode with a few dancing secondaries with a big load of wood? (it’s very beautiful in this mode, and I try to get this before overnight.) Also of course if I knew the temperature at the cat it would be a no brainer at start up to know when the cat lights off instead of wondering. I kind of stress about that a bit on a cold start. I know I’d stress about it less if I just let the stove get a bit hotter before I engaged it. Also I’ll have more information as the cat starts to age and get toward failing.

So, I’d like to/am determined to probe the cat and see what’s going on. I’ve never been able to get an answer from anyone about how to do this, few people seem to have done it. After having the stove and thinking about it, looking under the hood, taking out a bolt, it’s pretty clear to me that a probe goes in to the bolt hole (seems to be 1/4” but not sure how it’s threaded) nearest the chimney. The probe needs to be long, 8 to 10 inches, to get to the outlet of the cat, which is facing toward the front of the stove. Not sure if the probe would rest on the metal housing around the cat (with heat exchangers, so it’s already losing heat) or measure the exhaust gas. Auber has a 10” inconel probe for about $20 (WRNK-191), seems to be the one to get. However when I called the support person there had a very heavy ( Chinese?) accent, and between that and my hearing loss it was quite excruciating trying to understand very much of what he was saying. He was trying to tell me something about which part of the probe could take what temperature, but I really couldn’t get it and was too polite to say, “Please, could I talk to someone else?” I’ve also looked at a million inconel thermocouple probes online, quite a bewildering set of choices. For $20 I’ll try this Auber one first.

Nobody seems to make a non thermocouple (Condar type) probe that length. I called Condar.

As an aside, it’s super weird that this stove used to ship with a probe, but they stopped doing that. When I was at Woodstock after I installed my stove I had both Tom and Lorin in the room, a really nice chat, but when I asked about probing the cat they got kind of funny. There was definitely a look between them before Lorin said something like, “I find it’s easiest to run my stove based on the stove top thermometer, how about you Tom?” Which may be true, but still I want to know about what’s going on in the cat. I’m guessing they had too many support calls about it, or people freak out when the cat gets very hot, or both. And they didn’t respond to my “But what if I just want to know?” They just plain don’t support it, though the stove does have a bolt hole for a probe. I’ve gleaned that. I’m guessing there is nothing bad from my end about knowing what’s going on with the cat, except it may cause stress if I find the cat is going thermonuclear all the time. But if it is, I can’t deal with that situation if I don’t know.

I also haven’t probed the chimney. I’ve never worried about the chimney temp before, as I’ve had non cat stoves here for decades and the chimney was plenty hot, which kept it clean except for a bit of soot. The progress is sucking a lot of heat out before sending it up the chimney. I think my liner is uninsulated. That’s a good guess. Done before my time. The chimney seems to run pretty cool right of this stove. So I’d like to probe both.

There are inexpensive battery powered dual channel thermocouple monitors out there for < $100. Are these OK? They take mini plugs.

Auber also has a single channel wifi enabled monitor for about $200, which would be sweet (I guess I would use that one for the cat monitor), and then I’d need another box for the other probe if I did that.

So bottom line, thinking of getting a 10” and 3” thermocouple probe, cat and chimney, and then read those with one or two display devices. Seem reasonable?
 
They have a 4,6,or 10" probe option in the "sensor options" drop down arrow. This is what many here use to monitor their flue temp. I have on in my flue and a second probe in place of the analog, magnetic cat thermometer on my BK. They work great.

 
Yes, that’s the 10” I was talking to the support guy about. According to an old Progress parts diagram, 8” is what was shipped before. I think I’ll try this 10 though.
 
As someone with a 3 or 4 year old distorted catalyst in my Progress who Woodstock has repeatedly ignored, I'm very interested in this. I've actually toyed with the idea of building a new top plate out of ~1" steel with a small window close enough to the catalyst to be able to visually confirm what it's doing. The only thing that's always held me back is that I would want a moderately high safety margin between the glass temperature rating and the potential catalyst temps, which I don't think exists in any kind of consumer option.

The first year I had the stove I black boxed it occasionally but have stopped going that route entirely. Secondary flames are now a requirement for me when the cat is engaged, but in either situation I think I could count on one hand how many times the stove top has been much past the 550 range.
 
I try pretty hard not to black box it, but when I go to bed it’s a unique situation, and I’ve never stayed up to see what happens. With the firebox full, on top of coals, you’ve got that knife edge between some secondaries, a black box, and the firebox blasting away. I guess out of the three, the latter is probably better for the catalyst and plate. If I go to bed on that knife edge I think it’s likely to tip one way or the other after some time. All in all it doesn’t matter for the outcome. It seems no matter what, I wake up to good coals and a warm room. I think better to err on the side of a little more air though in the first month or so with the stove I probably erred on the side of less air.

I’m going to get the 10” probe and a display from Auber. It’s a lot more money for a data logger, but that would be ideal to see what happens over time. I won’t go that route. I think a data logger is about $500 or so.

It’s a shame they are ignoring you. They definitely had quite the reputation for support and making things right. It’s why I got this stove! That support doesn’t seem to be quite as much of a thing these days.
 
I ordered the 10” probe from Auber along with their wifi enabled display box. If anyone cares I’ll report what it shows the cat is doing. I did burn the stove this weekend, but the 10 day weather forecast shows absurdly mild mini split weather for the foreseeable future. Definitely an easy on the woodpile start to the season.
 
I ordered the 10” probe from Auber along with their wifi enabled display box. If anyone cares I’ll report what it shows the cat is doing. I did burn the stove this weekend, but the 10 day weather forecast shows absurdly mild mini split weather for the foreseeable future. Definitely an easy on the woodpile start to the season.
I also have the satellite unit monitoring my flue temps from my bedroom nightstand. Thats how I ended up with two separate Auber's. I wished I ordered the combo pack after getting a single display to monitor the flue temps, so I did.
 
Ah, I didn’t know about a combo pack. I got this one:


I got a magnet washer and also the 10” inconel thermocouple for the cat. I can easily (I hope) swap between them, both with the same plug. Mostly my goal is to understand the stove a bit better. I probably don’t need to monitor everything constantly but I’ll see what I settle into. If the cat isn’t going into the stratosphere, then the chimney magnet will probably suffice. If I see the cat is popping up to 1600 or 2000F easily, then I’ll keep that as the active probe.
 
Condar doesn’t have a probe for your stove? They made me a 10” cat probe with a 90 degree bend so I could actually read it for the back of my Fireview. It’s not as accurate as a thermocouple but it seems close enough and I don’t have wires to deal with.

I think what gives me the most info running my stove is flue temps. Much quicker to react than stove top temps. My cat temps lag slightly behind flue temps while in the bypass mode so I kind a watch both for knowing when to engage the cat.

I guess there are many variables and different setups so maybe using the stove top as a standard guide keeps Woodstock from having to answer too many questions from people that go down the cat/flue/stove temp rabbit hole. Wood stove nerds like us like all this info but for most it probably confuses more than helps.

As far as cat temps go I’ve read and been told anything over 1600 is bad for the cat but I’ve also been told by Woodstock that 1400 is not very good for cast iron and can cause warping over time. I haven’t seen anything over 1200 yet and it seems to cruise between 800-1100 depending on the air setting. This is with a steel cat. In the past with ceramic cats I’ve seen higher temps especially in black box mode.
 
Interesting. Thanks! I did see the Condar 10” cat this time around. Last year after I got the stove I called Condar and asked about a probe for the Progress. They had no information at all about it, “We don’t have a probe for that stove.” That was before I did my own detective work and figured out what I *think* I need, since nobody will tell me. After last burning season I I opened the top cover and put a bamboo skewer through the hole where the bolt is. It sits right above the front of the cat at 10”. So that’s what I got. But I also saw in an old Progress parts diagram a listing for an 8” probe.

The other info I don’t have is exactly what thread that bolt is. Auber sells fittings with NPT and BSP threads (which I had to look up). Apparently not interchangeable, so I don’t want to screw around as it were and ruin the threads. I guess I’ll just jam it in there.

I thought about just getting the condar at the last minute before I ordered, but the dial would be in the back and sort of behind the heat shield. Not impossible, but not great. Certainly a lot cheaper!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Todd
This is what Condar made for me. It was an 8.5” probe with a 90 bend and 1.5” dial. It gets me about 3/4” away from the cat. It cost me $46 with shipping.
 

Attachments

  • [Hearth.com] Thermocouples, Cat and Pipe Monitoring, Progress Hybrid
    IMG_2860.webp
    381.9 KB · Views: 33
This is what Condar made for me. It was an 8.5” probe with a 90 bend and 1.5” dial. It gets me about 3/4” away from the cat. It cost me $46 with shipping.
I like that 90 deg, also for my BK!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Todd
Got my gear from Auber yesterday two thermocouples and the SYL-2332 display/wifi box. I can just swap between the two probes I bought without any setup change or reset, so I can monitor chimney or cat with a plug swap. Wifi app is set up. The positive surprise is that it does show history with a graph in the app, up to 5 hours, so that is fun and useful. It has an alarm which I have not tested, but both the device (optional, with a button) and the app.

I’m pretty geeky and used to do some tech writing a million years ago, sometimes for engineering shops that made something like this box, so my job was to try to steal some time from the engineers and try to translate for non-engineers. I’m not sure if they used a real tech writer here. The SYL-2332 and its underlying box has a whole lot more going on (more potential purposes I think) than woodstove monitoring, so it’s a bit overwhelming at first to sort through all that. Sort of a simple plug and play, but not exactly.

It will be another week (!) before I fire the stove, probably. Nights have been in the 50s, in November, in Vermont. The mini split heat is practically free at these temps, and the big stove is better for <32F.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Todd
Bent the probe a bit, I think it sits in front of the cat nicely as long as it doesn’t spin on its axis. I cut some small gasket which made a tiny tube and put the probe through it to jam the hole. It doesn’t sit tightly in the bolt hole as well as I’d like, and I don’t want to gob stove cement in there, but that might be the best option. I kind of want to be able to keep the hole suitable to put the bolt back into but that might not matter so much? I’ve got the wire clipped to the heat shield with a cotter pin clip I had around — there is probably a better clip I can find. That seems to press it semi snugly in place.
 

Attachments

  • [Hearth.com] Thermocouples, Cat and Pipe Monitoring, Progress Hybrid
    IMG_0256.webp
    418.6 KB · Views: 30
I can see my cat, and I often see that the corners have a different (often slightly lower) temperature than the center.
I don't know how much that would show in the reading you're making.
Just FYI
 
Ah thanks. I suppose I could try to get the bend to go away from the edge instead of down, but the hole in the back is where the hole is, near the edge. I guess I’ll consider when I get readings that the middle of the cat could be higher.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Todd and stoveliker
I know,.you work with what you have. It was just info.
 
  • Like
Reactions: John Lehet and Todd
Yeah when I had the Auber probe I had to bend it a bit to get it more centered for my previous Fireview and Keystones. I was always tempted to drill down from the top to set a thermometer dead center but couldn’t bring myself to do it. It may be a little cooler off to the side but how much, 100-200 degrees maybe? You will still get good info from it.
 
On the Keystone and Fireview, the Condar probe seemed to give me temps that I'd expect near the flue exit. I don't think the long analog probe can transmit the tip temp all the way back to the dial, it gets diluted before it gets there. The temp on the long Condar might be showing 800-900 when the cat was glowing orange and stove cruising. I knew from the shorter probes in the Dutchwest (2") and the Buck 91 (6") that the actual cat temp with that sort of glow was more like 1200 or better. That was later confirmed when I got an Auber digital probe in there.
Ideally, you'd like the tip of the probe about 3/4" from the face of the cat. The cat lies flatter in the Ks and Fv than it appears to in the Progress, so probably a little tougher to get the probe tip where you want it in the Progress.
I used a small piece of stainless trim coil stuffed into the probe hole, and kept bending it into different configurations until I hit on something that held the probe where I wanted it.
 
Maybe it’s why Woodstock is not in favor of the cat probes. Maybe dial 10” probes just don’t give real info. And electronic probes would be too much for them to support maybe.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Todd
I'm going to use whatever I can to help me keep the cat temp from going high. I don't know how long it takes for 1500+ temps to start degrading the cat, but at the current prices for the steel cats, I don't want to find out. _g I can use ceramic cats in my stoves but I don't know if that's an option for the Progress..
 
  • Like
Reactions: Todd
On the Keystone and Fireview, the Condar probe seemed to give me temps that I'd expect near the flue exit. I don't think the long analog probe can transmit the tip temp all the way back to the dial, it gets diluted before it gets there. The temp on the long Condar might be showing 800-900 when the cat was glowing orange and stove cruising. I knew from the shorter probes in the Dutchwest (2") and the Buck 91 (6") that the actual cat temp with that sort of glow was more like 1200 or better. That was later confirmed when I got an Auber digital probe in there.
Ideally, you'd like the tip of the probe about 3/4" from the face of the cat. The cat lies flatter in the Ks and Fv than it appears to in the Progress, so probably a little tougher to get the probe tip where you want it in the Progress.
I used a small piece of stainless trim coil stuffed into the probe hole, and kept bending it into different configurations until I hit on something that held the probe where I wanted it.
I’m seeing 900 with a dull red glowing cat with this Condar probe and over 1000 when it turns bright. There could be some temp influence from how close the dial is to the stove?
 

Attachments

  • [Hearth.com] Thermocouples, Cat and Pipe Monitoring, Progress Hybrid
    image.webp
    174.4 KB · Views: 19
dull red seems about right for 900 F imo (having looked at glowing material by eye for a few decades of my life, to estimate the temperature after having calibrated myself with a dual wavelength pyrometer).
 
Condar can custom make these but it’s only 7.5” from the edge of the dial. They said their longest probe is 8.5”
Can the tip of your bent probe reach past the edge of the cast iron cat frame, or is it a little short of actually getting over the cat itself (assuming you're using the ceramic cat with cast frame.) My Condar (not bent) is 8" actual probe length not including dial and spacer, and it clears the back edge of the cast cat frame, with maybe 3/4" or so over the cat face.
I’m seeing 900 with a dull red glowing cat with this Condar probe and over 1000 when it turns bright. There could be some temp influence from how close the dial is to the stove?
I wouldn't think much influence from radiation to the bi-metal strip; Has to be a good 1/2" away from the cast iron flue collar assembly, and that's probably running ax, no?

dull red seems about right for 900 F imo (having looked at glowing material by eye for a few decades of my life, to estimate the temperature after having calibrated myself with a dual wavelength pyrometer).
True, dull red is about 900, but the 1000 that Todd reports when the cat is "bright" is way low; more like 1300-1400 or more depending on how bright "bright" is. If it's bright orange, almost pushing yellow, it's past 1500 for sure.
 
True, dull red is about 900, but the 1000 that Todd reports when the cat is "bright" is way low; more like 1300-1400 or more depending on how bright "bright" is. If it's bright orange, almost pushing yellow, it's past 1500 for sure.
Yeah, how bright is bright.
Can't say.