Wood Stove install - Through wall to clay flue thimble

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.

ZScott

New Member
Nov 12, 2024
7
Central Pennsylvania
Hello -

I am planning on installing a Jøtul F 55 V2 Carrabassett in the basement of my home. My primary question is regarding the correct way (and part names) to connect my new stove to an existing clay flue which connects to my existing masonry chimney. I'd like to use double wall stove pipe.

A little background: The home was built in 1984, and we recently took possession this year (so I have no information on original construction, etc.). I recently discovered during a cleaning/inspection of my fireplace & chimney that the existing chimney (currently serves the fireplace) has a second flue. After a opening the basement wall (and following some original builder pencil outlines/markings) I was able to locate a clay thimble connecting to the secondary flue in my chimney. This flue was very obviously never used, and there are no existing connections. I would ideally like to connect to this flue when installing my new stove. I'm in the process of renovating the basement to build a hearth and clear the space needed, my only confusion is the actual connection to the flue. I can find a lot of information on passing through a wall, as well as passing through masonry walls to connect to the chimney, but not this combination that I have of a combustible wall to a masonry chimney.

The framed off opening measures about 17.25" x 17.25". The clearance from the thimble to the frame varies between 4.5" and 5.5" (all under 6"). The clay thimble itself is just over 8" Inner Diameter and measures approximately 17 7/8" in length. The frame is standard 2x4 studs, and there is what seems to be a styrofoam panel between the studs and the cinderblock base of the chimney (which is what I cut through to cut out the clay thimble). The chimney does not have any modern/metal liners; from running my phone camera inside I can see what appears to be the clay flue/liner all the way up the chimney.

A secondary observation that I have is that I cannot locate any cleanout doors to the chimney (unless those are covered as well), and I'm not sure if that will be an issue when I proceed with the installation of the wood stove. I can continue to check for cleanout doors, but that would require cutting out that styrofoam panel on the inside of the basement, or tearing off stone veneer on the outside of the chimney (and I'm doubtful they would have veneered over a cleanout door).

I also noticed that the base of the secondary flue terminates at the cinderblock foundation of the chimney, and the tops of the cinderblocks open (i.e.: debris, soot, etc., can just fall into the block below. I'm not sure if this was an oversite and should be closed off, or if this is either non-factor or an intentional design.

Any help is greatly appreciated. Apologies for any miss-used terminology, I'm new to most of this.

Thanks.
-Zach
 

Attachments

  • [Hearth.com] Wood Stove install - Through wall to clay flue thimble
    ClayThimble-Length.webp
    172.8 KB · Views: 55
  • [Hearth.com] Wood Stove install - Through wall to clay flue thimble
    ClayThimble-ID.webp
    63.7 KB · Views: 42
  • [Hearth.com] Wood Stove install - Through wall to clay flue thimble
    ClayThimble.webp
    168.4 KB · Views: 46
  • [Hearth.com] Wood Stove install - Through wall to clay flue thimble
    WallOpening.webp
    176.3 KB · Views: 54
Welcome. It's good you have asked these questions. The thimble does not have proper clearances. The stove manual state's what is required regarding this type of thimble for a wall pass-thru. There may be a cleanout (or not) below this thimble.
[Hearth.com] Wood Stove install - Through wall to clay flue thimble

What is the clay liner ID in this chimney? If the chimney doesn't have proper clearances from combustibles, the safest approach is to install an insulated 6" stainless liner in the chimney with an insulated thimble passing through the wall.
 
Thank you! I appreciate the speedy reply.

I did my best to take a rough measurement of the ID of the chimney. It is rectangular in shape and measures approximately 6.5" x 12.5" (give or take, I can only measure through the thimble right now, as I cannot reach the chimney top).

If I'm reading the diagram correctly, the thimble should have a 12" clearance from the studs on all sides. Is that correct? If so, is there any type of connection to reduce that distance? If not, I presume the best option then is to reframe the thimble to give that 12" minimum clearance. If I did that, it looks like the requirement is also that that opening is lined with some type of masonry/brick surrounding the thimble?

I need to renovate that corner anyway (I'm also planning on putting up a stone veneer wall), so I'm completely open to reframing if needed.

And once I have the correct dimensions, I'm still a little confused on what the correct adapter is to allow me to connect to the thimble. I presume there is some type of adapter that would feed into that thimble, to which I would then hook up the chimney pipe?

Edit: I forgot to mention that the chimney is constructed of come type of cement block, in case it is relevant. The base is definitely your standard cinderblock, as I can see that looking down through/inspecting from the outside. The distance measuring from the end of the thimble (the start of the inside of the chimney) to the wall studs is approximately 20".

Thank you in advance for the advice!
 
Last edited:
The stove needs a flue area of about 28 sq in. If the stove is connected to a 6.5" x 12.5" ID flue, that is almost a 3x increase to 81.5 sq in. This is strongly recommended against because it will slow down and cool the exhaust gases from the stove. This can result in weak draft, a cranky stove, hard starts, etc. It has the potention for significant creosote accumulation. Referring again to the manual:

The cross-sectional area of the flue of a chimney with one or more walls exposed to the outside below the roofline may be no more than two times the cross-sectional area of the stove flue collar.

If the chimney liner is too large to accommodate the stove, an approved relining system must be installed to resize the flue.
 
Thank you, this makes more sense now. What was misleading me was in section 2.1:
The fireclay flue liner must have a nominal size of 8” X 8”, and should not be larger than 8”X 12”. A round fireclay liner must have a minimum inside diameter of 6”and maximum inside diameter of 8”.A larger chimney should be relined with an appropriate code approved liner

I'm presuming my flue actually measures around 6"x12", which was falling into the aforementioned requirements. However, I missed the following section regarding the exposed walls/cross-sectional requirements. So based on this, my rectangular flue definitely requires a liner per the manufacture specifications.

I will need to coordinate the installation of the liner with other work I am having done soon.

I have one last question regarding "Figure 5. Masonry Wall Pass-through" in the manual (your initial reference). I read through that section and cannot determine for certain if I need to line that opening with brick as the manual states. The reason I am questioning this is that the chimney sits against the foundation in the basement. The cinderblocks used in the foundation have a width of 12", leaving 6" (given the 18" thimble) for the wall of the chimney and the chimney liner. They ran the thimble flush with the inner wall of the foundation.

The manual states:
The bricks must be solid brick with a minimum of 3 inches thick (nominal 4”).Refractory mortar must be used at the junction of the chimney and the pass-through liner. The pass-through liner must not penetrate the chimney liner beyond the inner surface of the chimney liner.

It seems like this installation meets all of these requirements, the only difference being there may not be an air gap between the chimney and the foundation wall, but there is and air gap between the studs and the foundation wall. If this does fulfill the requirements, I would assume all I need to do to bring this portion up to code is to expand the distance from thimble to studs to a minimum of 12".

So my questions are:
  1. Do I still need to line the framed opening with brick?
  2. If so, do I then need to extend the thimble to be flush with the brick (as in the diagram)?
Thanks again for all of the help.
 

Attachments

  • [Hearth.com] Wood Stove install - Through wall to clay flue thimble
    ThimbleInFoundation_1.webp
    413.4 KB · Views: 43
  • [Hearth.com] Wood Stove install - Through wall to clay flue thimble
    ThimbleInFoundation_2.webp
    331.5 KB · Views: 44
They make insulated pass-thrus for this purpose. This article discusses some options :

 
Thank you for all of your help. This all makes a lot more sense now, and I definitely would have missed the flue size issue if you had not pointed it out. That article (and the reference link to the insulated wall pass thru) is extremely helpful (and my existing pass thru proves the point that most are incorrect and a hazard...). I'll weigh my options from here, fortunately they are pretty open given my remodel plans. Glad this was caught early, and thanks again!
 
  • Like
Reactions: begreen and bholler
Hello Again - I have a follow up question and thought it would be best to list it here with the original context, hopefully that is fine.

I have a contractor lined up for work on the chimney, including installing a chimney liner. However, the wall thimble is setting too close to the bottom of the flue/chimney and doesn't leave space for the "T" pipe the contractor will use (terminates the liner at the thimble/has a cleanout) will not fit. He is recommending tearing out the existing thimble and part of the wall/chimney to move it ~4-6" higher. He said that I can do demo myself and provide the thimble, and he can keep the liner installation at about the same price (~$1400). I'm still waiting on a quote from the contractor if I let him do the demo.

My question is this: Is a "T" style pipe the only method to terminate the liner? Since I will have no access to the cleanout anyway (without significant remodeling of the chimney and foundation wall) I was hoping there would be an alternate method (e.g.: something "L" shaped that does not require additional clearance for the cleanout portion of the "T" style pipe).

My biggest hesitation here is that I remeasured my flue and I'm now fairly confident on an ID of 6" on the short side and what seems to be under 10" on the long side. Unfortunately I can't access the flue well enough to confirm the long side. So if the flue actually measures 6"x9" or less, this would actually put me under the upper threshold defined by the manufacturer of ~56.5" ("The cross-sectional area of the flue ... may be no more than two times the cross-sectional area of the stove flue collar.").

So I obviously don't want to tear up my wall and chimney if the flue ends up already meeting the stove specifications. I'd also consider just having the liner installed anyway (since I'm on the upper end of flue size regardless), if I didn't need to demo the wall and there was some alternative to the "T" terminating pipe the contractor would use. The contractor will not charge me for any parts or labor if the liner is not needed. So my gamble here is all on tearing out the wall in advance to save money, and I want to know all options to make the best decision here.

Note: My chimney is extremely difficult to access (about 30 feet up, non-walkable roof, and the chimney side of the house is on a steep decline). So neither I or the contractor can measure the exact dimensions until they have already set up scaffolding and began the job. At which point, I won't have time to do any of the cost-saving prep work myself and will need to pay the contractor.
 
Hello Again - I have a follow up question and thought it would be best to list it here with the original context, hopefully that is fine.

I have a contractor lined up for work on the chimney, including installing a chimney liner. However, the wall thimble is setting too close to the bottom of the flue/chimney and doesn't leave space for the "T" pipe the contractor will use (terminates the liner at the thimble/has a cleanout) will not fit. He is recommending tearing out the existing thimble and part of the wall/chimney to move it ~4-6" higher. He said that I can do demo myself and provide the thimble, and he can keep the liner installation at about the same price (~$1400). I'm still waiting on a quote from the contractor if I let him do the demo.

My question is this: Is a "T" style pipe the only method to terminate the liner? Since I will have no access to the cleanout anyway (without significant remodeling of the chimney and foundation wall) I was hoping there would be an alternate method (e.g.: something "L" shaped that does not require additional clearance for the cleanout portion of the "T" style pipe).

My biggest hesitation here is that I remeasured my flue and I'm now fairly confident on an ID of 6" on the short side and what seems to be under 10" on the long side. Unfortunately I can't access the flue well enough to confirm the long side. So if the flue actually measures 6"x9" or less, this would actually put me under the upper threshold defined by the manufacturer of ~56.5" ("The cross-sectional area of the flue ... may be no more than two times the cross-sectional area of the stove flue collar.").

So I obviously don't want to tear up my wall and chimney if the flue ends up already meeting the stove specifications. I'd also consider just having the liner installed anyway (since I'm on the upper end of flue size regardless), if I didn't need to demo the wall and there was some alternative to the "T" terminating pipe the contractor would use. The contractor will not charge me for any parts or labor if the liner is not needed. So my gamble here is all on tearing out the wall in advance to save money, and I want to know all options to make the best decision here.

Note: My chimney is extremely difficult to access (about 30 feet up, non-walkable roof, and the chimney side of the house is on a steep decline). So neither I or the contractor can measure the exact dimensions until they have already set up scaffolding and began the job. At which point, I won't have time to do any of the cost-saving prep work myself and will need to pay the contractor.
The bottom of the tee can just be trimmed down.
 
Thanks for the advice. I didn't even consider that trimming the tee was an option. I'll talk to my contractor and see what he says.

Note: I had forgotten to mention that the thimble is basically on the bottom block of the foundation/chimney wall, so there is about 1.25"-1.5" of clearance. The tee he sent me a picture of has a cap that goes over the bottom to close it off that appears to be more than 1.5". So I'm not sure if that's the problem. Or if the cap is even required. Just throwing out the details I forgot, either way I'll check with my contractor.
 
A cap on the bottom is definitely required. You don't want air to be sucked into the liner. That will cool the flue gases and weaken draft.