I can read that many don't like Vermont Castings, but...

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.

regalmalette

New Member
Sep 23, 2026
6
Concord NH
Hello Hearth.com

After this season, I'm retiring my Vermont Castings Defiant 1945 making it 20 years of heavy use. I burn about five cords per season (November through April), and the stove essentially runs 24/7. Overall, it's been a great investment. My setup drafts exceptionally well thanks to an interior Selkirk chimney, and I've almost exclusively used the top-loading feature, which has been one of my favorite aspects of the stove.

Over the years, maintenance could be tedious because of the fragile refractory assembly and catalyst, but I learned the system and have access to local Vermont Castings dealers. As parts gradually warped from use, I was able to replace them as needed and keep the stove running.

Now that I'm shopping for a replacement, I'm strongly considering the Defiant 1975. The refractory design appears far more robust, the catalyst is only 1 inch thick instead of 2 inches (making replacement significantly less expensive), and after two decades of service I feel it's time for a complete reset with fresh gaskets and new components.

Several people have suggested looking beyond Vermont Castings, saying there are "simpler" and "more reliable" stoves that require less maintenance. I've also heard comments that the Defiant is "a good stove but not a good furnace." However, when I compare options, I find very few stoves that offer top loading. For me, that feature may be enough reason to stay with the Defiant. While the Defiant can be loaded through the front door, I've probably loaded from the top 99% of the time because it's simply easier and cleaner.

My experience with the Defiant has largely been "set it and forget it." Once the stove is brought up to temperature properly and the thermostat is set, it can run for weeks with nothing more than minor adjustments to the thermostat, and reloading every 6-8 hours. Looking back, I likely overfired it more than I realized by waiting too long to close the damper, which probably contributed to some of the warped components over the years.

For those who recommend other brands, how much simpler and more reliable are they in real-world use? Would the benefits be significant enough that I wouldn't miss the convenience of top loading?

I also see a lot of criticism of Vermont Castings, with comments about declining quality and a poor reputation. Can anyone point to specific issues? My Defiant 1945 lasted 20 years under heavy use, and the 1975's interior design looks considerably more durable than the refractory box in my current stove. Beyond that they both appear to be the same cast iron and glass, same upper damper, same ash tray, griddle and air controls?

I did search and read previous posts that I thought would be relevant, but feel free to respond with a link to a relevant post if you think this is captured elsewhere, thanks.
 
If you're getting good results with the Defiant, then I'd stick with it.

Why are you replacing the 1945? I've been using the same wood stove (non-VC and non-cat) 35 years and while I'd like to get something new it isn't because there is anything wrong with it.
 
The stove has a few warped parts, most notably the upper fireback, which is badly warped and affects how tightly it closes. Replacing cast iron components isn't always straightforward because the surrounding parts that aren't being replaced are also somewhat warped, making fitment unpredictable.

I'd also be replacing the refractory box for the second time while I have it apart. The parts alone would run about $1,000 before any unexpected issues are discovered. That's still much less expensive than buying a new stove, but the thought of going several years without a summer stove repair project, aside from sweeping the flue, is pretty appealing.
 
I have the Encore 2040 and it's been my main heat source.. I burn from October through April. There's no babysitting this stove. Basically get it to temperature and let it run. 12+hours of burn time are awesome. I found the aftermarket gaskets to be of a lower quality but that's not VCs fault.

During my initial search I looked at Lopi and blaze king.
 
Thanks. Seems to me I used to be closer to a 12 hour burn time. These days its closer to 8. I get a 200-degree temperature differential between griddle and flue. I wish I had duel thermometers when the stove was new, just to see what the temp reduction was back then.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Turbo89
I bought the VC Defiant 1975-C in 2022. Ran it for 3 full seasons. Undoubtedly, it provided great heat which we came to absolutely love and I reduced our heating oil usage by almost 50%. But I have some....buts....

Some will view this opinion as bashing the stove, so feel free to take it or leave it. I'm honestly not bashing it - these are my real world experiences and it seems like that's what you're looking for.

I babysat that Defiant around the clock, never felt comfortable going to bed or leaving the house unless that stove was in a coaling stage. I experienced backpuffs, overfires, no burn time above 4 hours, and honestly was losing my patience as our stove install is in our basement (walk out with a slider door for fresh air 8 feet away) and I was up and down them basement stairs 50-60 times a day. I bought the Auber probe as recommended and hooked up a baby monitor so I could see temps from the room above. Still found myself going downstairs to adjust something that never fixed the "issue". At my best operation, I ran the secondary at recommended temps (1000-1300)...and still warped two metal cats (look in the VC 2025/2026 performance thread for those pictures). My refractory access cover fell off in the 2nd burning season. Wasn't a huge deal, I just used gasket to hold it in place, but it was obvious the tiny feet wore completely off it and a terrible design. I replaced every gasket I could without breaking down the stove and seriously considered rebuilding it. I realigned and tightened all the doors. I kept the ash pan full ALL the time which finally provided some stability and some longer burn times. It just personally felt like I was losing the battle but continued to fight it.

Last year in February an opportunity came up for me to grab a new stove at reasonable money. I also found a buyer for my VC Defiant that removed the stove from my house - and yes, I did share all of this feedback with that buyer and he still paid me cash for it on the spot. The VC Defiant I think went out of our house on a Wednesday and the new stove came in on a Friday. I lit that new stove on that Friday and it ran for 6 straight days to my delight.

I'm running a stove that admittedly has a terrible name - an Ambiance Hipster 20. It's a subsidiary of Hearthstone and if you honestly compare the stove to the Green Mountain 60, they are pretty much identical stoves. This stove is outperforming the VC Defiant in every category - remember- my experience in my house on my chimney with my wood (it's dry) on my time. I've had no runaways, no overfires, burn cycles of 9-12 hours, beautiful heat, nice looking stove with a really awesome secondary tube burn in the back that looks like a vortex. Just the other night I loaded it at 10pm on a bed of coals, and it was producing heat hot enough that I couldn't touch the stove at 6am. I opened the air and it chugged along another 2 hours before I loaded it.

Honestly, couldn't be happier to not be with that VC Defiant. But again, this is my opinion and you are welcome to disagree.
 
Ok, I am headed over to the 26/27 VC Performance forum at this point - that seems like the place for my next round of follow up questions. Thanks for your help thusfar!
 
Smokey’s description is good (well bad for him), but there’s lots of stories like his on this forum. I’ve been running my VC encore for a few years now, and overall I like the stove; but it’s just finicky to operate relative to my old Jotuls and even my new Tommy PE Summit.

I spent the first season trying to troubleshoot and fix it, which resulted in me having to partially plug the secondary air intake so it wouldn’t run away; it also require a good cat thermometer to run, in my opinion thats not optional with a catalytic VC stove. Lastly they’re just sort of Rune Goldberg designs; they sure look great but it feels like the designers always chose more complex approaches to everything; and thus when they break they’re a PITA to fix and parts can be pricey.

All that being said, once I got the encore tuned in it’s been a great stove. 10+hr burns on a 2.5cu-ft fire box is pretty easy, and while I’d like 12+hrs; that’s pretty impressive for the stoves small firebox.
 
I have had an identical experience as Smokey with my Defiant 1975. I was very excited for the stove due to the top load, heat output, and aesthetically pleasing design. I wanted to love this stove. Now I run it as more of hobby, that I don't have time for. Being on the forums other VC designs seem to run a little more smoothly but most with this larger stove seem to have struggles. We have no definite answer as to why we have these regular run aways and fear a meltdown but I believe it has to with the the larger engine and smaller CAT, like you mentioned above. The smaller CAT helps the pocket book, but I think truly is a flaw for this size of unit. If the somewhat regular run aways warp the CAT every year, it's not longer helping on the cost front.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Smokey Da Bears