Burn Coal in Big Jim Fireplace Insert?

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
  • Hope everyone has a wonderful and warm Thanksgiving!
  • Super Cedar firestarters 30% discount Use code Hearth2024 Click here

Snoozeworm

New Member
Aug 16, 2018
6
West Virginia
Any information provided on this gem would be great! Google turned up 2 other people on Earth that own one of these. There must be someone here with knowledge. Picked up on Craiglist for $140 this summer and restored to this condition.

My question is, can it burn Coal too? It has air control through the ash pan. A THICK grate (no shaker) that allows ash to drop through .Oh and it's freaking heavy !
 
Any information provided on this gem would be great! Google turned up 2 other people on Earth that own one of these. There must be someone here with knowledge. Picked up on Craiglist for $140 this summer and restored to this condition.

My question is, can it burn Coal too? It has air control through the ash pan. A THICK grate (no shaker) that allows ash to drop through .Oh and it's freaking heavy !
I beleive they were meant to burn coal as well. But because there is no shaker they arent very good at it. Do you have a liner hooked to it?
 
I beleive they were meant to burn coal as well. But because there is no shaker they arent very good at it. Do you have a liner hooked to it?

No liner. The downstairs has an old squire wood stove insert that's been there since the house was built in the 70s. Chimney stays clean, no smoke, insert gets pulled and cleaned with chimney .I'm personally not sold on the absolute need for liners in every situation .I'm also not the smartest guy you'll talk to this week.
 
No liner. The downstairs has an old squire wood stove insert that's been there since the house was built in the 70s. Chimney stays clean, no smoke, insert gets pulled and cleaned with chimney .I'm personally not sold on the absolute need for liners in every situation .I'm also not the smartest guy you'll talk to this week.
Well burning wood in an insert with no liner isnt very smart. Burning coal that way is just plain dumb i am sorry to be so blunt. Coal exhaust is much cooler than wood which means less draft. Coal also puts off relatively high levels of co throught the whole burn. So the combination of no connection to an oversized flue low exhaust temps leading to weak draft and poisonous fumes just is not a good idea.
 
Bump for any more info or direction to an original manual. I'd pay via PayPal for the manual .Scanned or mailed.
It is very likely there was never a manual for it. What would you like to know.
 
I really enjoy reading the manual to my old squire. Honestly I'd love a confirmation of the coal burning and generally having the book to leaf through.
It clearly is meant to burn coal also that is what the bottom inlet is for. But if you want to burn coal you need a heavy wall 316 liner.
 
I'll look into that specific liner. Thank you. Are you able to point me in the general direction of what coal to look for. I'm in West Virginia so it shouldn't be rocket science to find some .I understand there is anthracite and bituminous, and that a stove is generally designed to burn one or the other? My local Lowe's sells anthracite "nut" coal...
 
I'll look into that specific liner. Thank you. Are you able to point me in the general direction of what coal to look for. I'm in West Virginia so it shouldn't be rocket science to find some .I understand there is anthracite and bituminous, and that a stove is generally designed to burn one or the other? My local Lowe's sells anthracite "nut" coal...
That depends on the grate size but most will do fine with nut anthracite. But it will be a pita without a shaker grate.