The Evergreen is a clean-looking design. The shallower firebox means it projects about 4" less into the room than the Super. It also has 3" closer side clearances if that is an issue. The Evergreen has a convection top, which is over the actual stovetop. The Super's top does not, the stovetop is exposed. This means the Super is easier to boil water on for cooking or coffee, but less friendly if your cat jumps on it when the stove is burning.