maple1
Minister of Fire
Of the two, I would go option 2.
Or, just get an inverter & call that good. Not sure on your outage situation but we can go a day easy without cycling the pump. If real bad weather is coming, you can just run a couple 5 gallon jugs full ahead of time. Having a good sized water tank will help there and also help in regular operation since then the pump won't cut in as much - should save a bit of juice. We also have 3 toilets in the house, so there's that too I guess.
Then if I really did need to be able to run the pump, I would get the second 240v gennie. There are always lots of low hour ones for sale used around here. Fuel consumption is the biggest part of getting through an outage here. Or minimizing it, I should say.
Or, just get an inverter & call that good. Not sure on your outage situation but we can go a day easy without cycling the pump. If real bad weather is coming, you can just run a couple 5 gallon jugs full ahead of time. Having a good sized water tank will help there and also help in regular operation since then the pump won't cut in as much - should save a bit of juice. We also have 3 toilets in the house, so there's that too I guess.
Then if I really did need to be able to run the pump, I would get the second 240v gennie. There are always lots of low hour ones for sale used around here. Fuel consumption is the biggest part of getting through an outage here. Or minimizing it, I should say.
Have a shallow well 120v water pump and lots of hot water in the water heater still. It's a bit of a pain having to do that manual stuff (pulling it outside the basement door & getting it going, then running a couple of extension cords), but it only took 10 minutes even while half asleep still, and it uses so little gas it's worth it, & does all we need in an outage. We have not much reason to have anything bigger - although having one around the same size that would put out 240v would be nice at times. That would be our ultimate setup - along with a generlink to plug it into. Champion makes what looks like might be a good candidate, but they don't sell them up here. 
