Looking back in records, Sept 1st, 2016

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.

EatenByLimestone

Moderator
Staff member
Hearth Supporter
I posted about the sadness of retiring my little Century and my brand spanking new T5!

Looks like this winter will mark a decade of warm toes, lol. I suppose a long term review is fitting?

Great stove! The only big maintenance has been repainting the top and new door/window gaskets (once for each). Edit: the flat gasket sealing the baffle has been changed twice!

I’ve cooked and reheated an awful lot on it. I also had a storm collar leak for a bit that it took me a while to fix. I wish that the flue collar was welded on. I suppose that they chose not to for a good reason. But that leak could have caused rust down in a crack that can’t easily be serviced.

The gaskets weren’t bad yet when changed, but they’d been in service for years and I got to wondering if a changeout would improve performance. They did a bit, but it wasn’t overwhelming, lol. The old gaskets must not have been horrible yet!

Every fall I squirt some liquid graphite spray on the latch mechanism and door hinges. Some people like powdered graphite, I make a mess with it and can’t get it where I want it. Spray works better for me. The oil pulls the graphite down into the crack then evaporates.

The chimney stays clean with wildly variable wood. I had one year where my 3 year old oak washed down the river in a spring flood. I got some white pine as it dries fast, and it washed down the river in a fall flood! I wasn’t a happy burner that year! I had to buy compressed sawdust and burn what I could scrounge. The stove processed it all like a champ!

If I could pick one thing I’d improve on the stove it’d be burn time. I’m in a windy area and I think that increases draft/shortens burn time a bit. The stove is a real easy breather. Hopefully the new T5s with the EBT do that. Chimney is 17 foot. 5 feet of singlewall and 12 feet of Class A. I have a key damper in the singlewall that fits really tight and helps when it’s like -20, lol. Everybody has a different definition of burn time so your experience on my stove in my cabin could be different, lol. I don’t really run the stove unless it’s 20-25F out down to well, -20 or so. I’d say normal reload is about every 7 hours. It gets shorter as it gets colder.

But I’m happy with the stove! I’ve got to admit that I sometimes get a grass is always greener on the other side of the fence and id love to try a cat stove in the cabin sometime. But I look at the price of them and if I asked my wife for permission I think she’d rather go on vacation with that money! Maybe in another 10-15 years the temptation will win out!
 
Good review, I’ve always wanted to try out the T5. I recommended it to my neighbors and they went with the Super 27 and love it. I think they get 10+ hours burns with it.

Keep an eye out for used stoves, you can probably sell your for the cost of a good used cat stove.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Burnin Since 1991
I don’t think I’ve ever been on a 10 hour reload cycle when I wasn’t on a light a fire and let it burn out schedule. That’s where I’d love to see what a cat stove would do on low.

The 7 hours isn’t bad for me. I’m middle aged now, I get to wake up at 3 am anyway, lol.

It’s a great stove. I’m sure the newer versions show an improvement in burn time, but may be a bit more difficult to run on less than ideal wood. Everything has a trade off! I think this stove has decades of life left in it. I think I recently read that PE has discontinued the first generation baffle assembly. I’m not sure what years those were made… 90s maybe? I see a lot of old Supers popping up here. Overall the T5/6/Super/Summit seem to be a rock solid designs that can last.
 
Nice review. Thanks for the update. I remember when you got that nice stove.

At 25º I definitely am burning more wood than at 35º and the burntime is shorter. The heat loss in our old farmhouse is noticeable at 25 and below. This is true with any stove as the heat demand from the stove increases to compensate for the heat loss of the house increasing with colder temps. Fortunately, we don't often do long forays into this temp range.

The original T5 and Super had a linked secondary air control that was coupled to the primary control. Only PE and Enviro had this and it was pretty effective. In testing, (in milder NW temps), Tom Oyen's shop got the longest burn time of any stove with the Super. - 16 hrs. This was softwood coals ready to restart, but still respectable.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Todd and GG Woody
Nice review, I got mine in December of 2016 too so I'm also going into my tenth season with it. No complaints with mine either - changed the door gasket once last year, baffle gasket almost every time I drop the baffle, and no other issues to speak of. I took a good look at my baffle this year a couple weeks ago during clean out and it does look pretty warped...no cracks or anything but I think after a decade of use it's taken some abuse.

I get good burn times with mine, 10-12 hr is typical for me although I judge it by a "usable coal bed" maybe more so than true heat output so really wood species plays a big role in that. A load of black locust and hickory like I was burning last year, I'd actually have some good size embers left in there after 20 hours. I too get curious about running a cat stove particularly in our upstate NY climate where it just seems like shoulder season really drags out in our early spring.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Todd