Possible to over-stuff fire box ?

  • Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment.

    We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues.

    We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.
I did no such thing, you are mistaken. The BK design is uniquely able to prevent overfire by closing the throttle automatically.

It must be assumed that the installation and operation is in compliance with the manual. Your strange argument otherwise is like saying, "but if you burn gasoline in the stove it could overfire".
And yet, the manual took time to specifically call out an overfire condition. One that is not entirely uncommon. BKVP would have to comment on why this is in the manual and whether this is the result of field reports or just overcautious CYA.
 
But.the manual of most stoves also mentions to not burn fossil fuels. Yet you never mention that as a warning when folks are discussing regular stove usage expectations.

That is the issue here.
 
But.the manual of most stoves also mentions to not burn fossil fuels. Yet you never mention that as a warning when folks are discussing regular stove usage expectations.

That is the issue here.
No, very wrong. That's an anomalous situations which is rarely brought up. Anyone that suggests that gets a quick rebuke, and you know that. Ad hominem attacks don't make right.
 
But we didn't suggest this and yet you provide a straw man rebuke...!
 
followed with strawman rebukes of 30 ft flues focussed on PE stoves.
 
Exactly, while calling my 30 ft thing wrong, highlighting where your car nonspec install remark was wrong too.

That was an example of how irrelevant and wrong it was to mention nonspec installation as a potential issue

Also, I do not believe I had ad hominem responses. I highlighted where what you wrote was inappropriate for the situation that was being discussed.
 
Last edited:
Like wrestling with a pig, I hand over this website to you. I'm outta here.
 
Not to enter the fray......
Guess I've been lucky.
Put a Princess in an uninsulated concrete foundation basement. Zero issue other than the completely expected heat loss.
Put a Princess in an uninsulated garage/shop. Zero issue as well.

Both basement and garage were eventually finished.

Yet to figure out what might put a BK over the edge;lol
We advise against uninsulated basements because experience has shown a few folks leave the door ajar thinking that will generate more heat. When in actuality, dry fuel and proper draft can produce advertised Btu's. Of course, as we all have seen for many years, uninsulated basements are a challenge regardless of model or brand of wood. As BeGreen has pointed out many, many times, heat is being absorbed by block or concrete walls and that keeps the worms happy.

As for the diagrams and why they are in wood stove manuals. Regulators have pushed for "overall firebox volume" vs "usable firebox volume", given it has to do with fuel load requirements in test methods. As a manufacturer we are required to show area used in testing. There are parties interested in proving "gaming" is taking place in testing. So, we now show where to load fuel and where not to.

Now, I've got a giant black locust tree to fall and deal with.....so be nice!

BKVP
 
One more thought.....we are all here to help provide information and guidance. First time visitors might leave when a pissing match between a bunch of over experienced fellas happens. Stick to the OP' (s) questions and folks will better appreciate all of you/us.

BKVP